Copyright (c) 2005 Robert N. M. Watson
All rights reserved.
Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
are met:
1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE AUTHOR AND CONTRIBUTORS ``AS IS'' AND
ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE
ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHOR OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE
FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL
DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS
OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION)
HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT
LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY
OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF
SUCH DAMAGE.
$P4: //depot/projects/trustedbsd/openbsm/man/audit.log.5#6 $
.Dd May 1, 2005 .Dt AUDIT.LOG 5 .Os .Sh NAME .Nm audit .Nd "Basic Security Module (BSM) File Format" .Sh DESCRIPTION The .Nm file format is based on Sun's Basic Security Module (BSM) file format, a token-based record stream to represent system audit data. This file format is both flexible and extensible, able to describe a broad range of data types, and easily extended to describe new data types in a moderately backward and forward compatible way.
p BSM token streams typically begin and end with a .Dv file token, which provides time stamp and file name information for the stream; when processing a BSM token stream from a stream as opposed to a single file source, file tokens may be seen at any point between ordinary records identifying when particular parts of the stream begin and end. All other tokens will appear in the context of a complete BSM audit record, which begins with a .Dv header token, and ends with a .Dv trailer token, which describe the audit record. Between these two tokens will appear a variety of data tokens, such as process information, file path names, IPC object information, MAC labels, socket information, and so on.
p The BSM file format defines specific token orders for each record event type; however, some variation may occur depending on the operating system in use, what system options, such as mandatory access control, are present.
p This manual page documents the common token types and their binary format, and is intended for reference purposes only. It is recommended that application programmers use the .Xr libbsm 3 interface to read and write tokens, rather than parsing or constructing records by hand. .Ss File Token The .Dv file token is used at the beginning and end of an audit log file to indicate when the audit log begins and ends. It includes a pathname so that, if concatenated together, original file boundaries are still observable, and gaps in the audit log can be identified. A .Dv file token can be created using .Xr au_to_file 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Seconds" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "File time stamp" t Li "Microseconds" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "File time stamp" t Li "File name lengh" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "File name of audit trail" t Li "File pathname" Ta "N bytes + 1 nul" Ta "File name of audit trail" .El .Ss Header Token The .Dv header token is used to mark the beginning of a complete audit record, and includes the length of the total record in bytes, a version number for the record layout, the event type and subtype, and the time at which the event occurred. A .Dv header token can be created using .Xr au_to_header32 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Record Byte Count" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Number of bytes in record" t Li "Version Number" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Record version number" t Li "Event Type" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Event type" t Li "Event Modifier" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Event sub-type" t Li "Seconds" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Record time stamp (32/64-bits)" t Li "Nanoseconds" Ta "4/8 byets" Ta "Record time stamp (32/64-bits)" .El .Ss Expanded Header Token The .Dv expanded header token is an expanded version of the .Dv header token, with the addition of a machine IPv4 or IPv6 address. The .Xr libbsm 3 API cannot currently create an .Dv expanded header token. l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Record Byte Count" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Number of bytes in record" t Li "Version Number" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Record version number" t Li "Event Type" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Event type" t Li "Event Modifier" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Event sub-type" t Li "Address Type/Length" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Host address type and length" t Li "Machine Address" Ta "4/16 bytes" Ta "IPv4 or IPv6 address" t Li "Seconds" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Record time stamp (32/64-bits)" t Li "Nanoseconds" Ta "4/8 byets" Ta "Record time stamp (32/64-bits)" .El .Ss Trailer Token The .Dv trailer terminates a BSM audit record, and contains a magic number, .Dv TRAILER_PAD_MAGIC and length that can be used to validate that the record was read properly. A .Dv trailer token can be created using .Xr au_to_trailer 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Trailer Magic" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Trailer magic number" t Li "Record Byte Count" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Number of bytes in record" .El .Ss Arbitrary Data Token The .Dv arbitrary data token contains a byte stream of opaque (untyped) data. The size of the data is calculated as the size of each unit of data multipled by the number of units of data. A .Dv How to print field is present to specify how to print the data, but interpretation of that field is not currently defined. The .Xr libbsm 3 API cannot currently create an .Dv arbitrary data token. l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "How to Print" Ta "1 byte" Ta "User-defined printing information" t Li "Basic Unit" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Size of a unit in bytes" t Li "Unit Count" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Number of units of data present" t Li "Data Items" Ta "Variable" Ta "User data" .El .Ss in_addr Token The .Dv in_addr token holds a network byte order IPv4 or IPv6 address. An .Dv in_addr token can be created using .Xr au_to_in_addr 3 for an IPv4 address, or .Xr au_to_in_addr_ex 3 for an IPv6 address.
p See the BUGS section for information on the storage of this token.
p l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "IP Address Type" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Type of address" t Li "IP Address" Ta "4/16 bytes" Ta "IPv4 or IPv6 address" .El .Ss Expanded in_addr Token The .Dv expanded in_addr token ...
p See the BUGS section for information on the storage of this token. l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t XXXX .El .Ss ip Token The .Dv ip token contains an IP packet header in network byte order. An .Dv ip token can be cread using .Xr au_to_ip 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Version and IHL" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Version and IP header length" t Li "Type of Service" Ta "1 byte" Ta "IP TOS field" t Li "Length" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "IP packet length in network byte order" t Li "ID" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "IP header ID for reassembly" t Li "Offset" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "IP fragment offset and flags, network byte order" t Li "TTL" Ta "1 byte" Ta "IP Time-to-Live" t Li "Protocol" Ta "1 byte" Ta "IP protocol number" t Li "Checksum" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "IP header checksum, network byte order" t Li "Source Address" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "IPv4 source address" t Li "Desintation Address" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "IPv4 destination address" .El .Ss Expanded ip Token The .Dv expanded ip token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t XXXX .El .Ss iport Token The .Dv iport token stores an IP port number in network byte order. An .Dv iport token can be created using .Xr au_to_iport 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Port Number" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Port number in network byte order" .El .Ss Path Token The .Dv path token contains a pathname. A .Dv path token can be created using .Xr auto_path 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Path Length" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Length of path in bytes" t Li "Path" Ta "N bytes + 1 nul" Ta "Path name" .El .Ss path_attr Token The .Dv path_attr token contains a set of nul-terminated path names. The .Xr libbsm 3 API cannot currently create an .Dv path_attr token. l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Count" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Number of nul-terminated string(s) in token" t Li "Path" Ta "Variable" Ta "count nul-terminated string(s)" .El .Ss Process Token The .Dv process token contains a description of the security properties of a process involved as the target of an auditable event, such as the destination for signal delivery. It should not be confused with the .Dv subject token, which describes the subject performing an auditable event. This includes both the traditional x security properties, such as user IDs and group IDs, but also audit information such as the audit user ID and sesion. A .Dv process token can be created using .Xr au_to_process32 3 or .Xr au_to_process64 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Audit ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit user ID" t Li "Effective User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective user ID" t Li "Effective Group ID "Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective group ID" t Li "Real User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real user ID" t Li "Real Group ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real group ID" t Li "Process ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Process ID" t Li "Session ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit session ID" t Li "Terminal Port ID" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Terminal port ID (32/64-bits)" t Li "Terminal Machine Address" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "IP address of machine" .El .Ss Expanded Process Token The .Dv expanded process token contains the contents of the .Dv process token, with the addition of a machine address type and variable length address storage capable of containing IPv6 addresses. A .Dv expanded process token can be created using .Xr au_to_process32_ex 3 or .Xr au_to_process64 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Audit ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit user ID" t Li "Effective User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective user ID" t Li "Effective Group ID "Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective group ID" t Li "Real User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real user ID" t Li "Real Group ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real group ID" t Li "Process ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Process ID" t Li "Session ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit session ID" t Li "Terminal Port ID" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Terminal port ID (32/64-bits)" t Li "Terminal Address Type/Length" Ta "1 byte" "Length of machine address" t Li "Terminal Machine Address" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "IPv4 or IPv6 address of machine" .El .Ss Return Token The .Dv return token contains a system call or library function return condition, including return value and error number associated with the global variable .Er errno . A .Dv return token can be created using .Xr au_to_return32 3 or .Xr au_to_return64 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Error Number" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Errno value, or 0 if undefined" t Li "Return Value" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Return value (32/64-bits)" .El .Ss Subject Token The .Dv subject token contains information on the subject performing the operation described by an audit record, and includes similar information to that found in the .Dv process and .Dv expanded process tokens. However, those tokens are used where the process being described is the target of the operation, not the authorizing party. A .Dv subject token can be created using .Xr au_to_subject32 3 and .Xr au_to_subject64 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Audit ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit user ID" t Li "Effective User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective user ID" t Li "Effective Group ID "Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective group ID" t Li "Real User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real user ID" t Li "Real Group ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real group ID" t Li "Process ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Process ID" t Li "Session ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit session ID" t Li "Terminal Port ID" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Terminal port ID (32/64-bits)" t Li "Terminal Machine Address" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "IP address of machine" .El .Ss Expanded Subject Token The .Dv expanded subject token consists of the same elements as the .Dv subject token, with the addition of type/length and variable size machine address information in the terminal ID. A .Dv expanded subject token can be created using .Xr au_to_subject32_ex 3 or .Xr au_to_subject64_ex 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Audit ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit user ID" t Li "Effective User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective user ID" t Li "Effective Group ID "Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Effective group ID" t Li "Real User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real user ID" t Li "Real Group ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Real group ID" t Li "Process ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Process ID" t Li "Session ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit session ID" t Li "Terminal Port ID" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Terminal port ID (32/64-bits)" t Li "Terminal Address Type/Length" Ta "1 byte" "Length of machine address" t Li "Terminal Machine Address" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "IPv4 or IPv6 address of machine" .El .Ss System V IPC Token The .Dv System V IPC token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Text Token The .Dv text token contains a single nul-terminated text string. A .Dv text token may be created using .Xr au_to_text 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Text Length" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Length of text string including nul" t Li "Text" Ta "N bytes + 1 nul" Ta "Text string including nul" .El .Ss Attribute Token The .Dv attribute token describes the attributes of a file associated with the audit event. As files may be identified by 0, 1, or many path names, a path name is not included with the attribute block for a file; optional .Dv path tokens may also be present in an audit record indicating which path, if any, was used to reach the object. A .Dv attribute token can be created using .Xr au_to_attr32 3 or .Xr au_to_attr64 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "File Access Mode" Ta "1 byte" Ta "mode_t associated with file" t Li "Owner User ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "uid_t associated with file" t Li "Owner Group ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "gid_t associated with file" t Li "File System ID" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "fsid_t associated with file" t Li "File System Node ID" Ta "8 bytes" Ta "ino_t associated with file" t Li "Device" Ta "4/8 bytes" Ta "Device major/minor number (32/64-bit)" .El .Ss Groups Token The .Dv groups token contains a list of group IDs associated with the audit event. A .Dv groups token can be created using .Xr au_to_groups 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Number of Groups" Ta "2 bytes" Ta "Number of groups in token" t Li "Group List" Ta "N * 4 bytes" Ta "List of N group IDs" .El .Ss System V IPC Permission Token The .Dv System V IPC permission token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Arg Token The .Dv arg token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss exec_args Token The .Dv exec_args token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss exec_env Token The .Dv exec_env token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Exit Token The .Dv exit token contains process exit/return code information. An .Dv exit token can be created using .Xr au_to_exit 3 . l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Status" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Process status on exit" t Li "Return Value" ta "4 bytes" Ta "Process return value on exit" .El .Ss Socket Token The .Dv socket token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Expanded Socket Token The .Dv expanded socket token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Seq Token The .Dv seq token contains a unique and monotonically increasing audit event sequence ID. Due to the limited range of 32 bits, serial number arithmetic and caution should be used when comparing sequence numbers. l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li "Sequence Number" Ta "4 bytes" Ta "Audit event sequence number" .El .Ss privilege Token The .Dv privilege token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Use-of-auth Token The .Dv use-of-auth token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Command Token The .Dv command token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss ACL Token The .Dv ACL token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Ss Zonename Token The .Dv zonename token ... l -column -offset ind ".Sy Field Name Width XX" ".Sy XX Bytes XXXX" ".Sy Description" t Sy "Field" Ta Sy Bytes Ta Sy Description t Li "Token ID" Ta "1 byte" Ta "Token ID" t Li XXXXX .El .Sh SEE ALSO .Xr libbsm 3 .Sh AUTHORS The Basic Security Module (BSM) interface to audit records and audit event stream format were defined by Sun Microsystems.
p This manual page was written by .An Robert Watson Aq rwatson@FreeBSD.org . .Sh HISTORY The OpenBSM implementation was created by McAfee Research, the security division of McAfee Inc., under contract to Apple Computer Inc. in 2004. It was subsequently adopted by the TrustedBSD Project as the foundation for the OpenBSM distribution. .Sh BUGS The .Dv How to print field in the .Dv arbitrary data token has undefined values.
p The .Dv in_addr and .Dv in_addr_ex token layout documented here appears to be in conflict with the .Xr libbsm 3 implementations of .Xr au_to_in_addr 3 and .Xr au_to_in_addr_ex 3 .