FAQ (131377) | FAQ (145474) |
---|---|
1 2 Frequently Asked Questions about zlib 3 4 5If your question is not there, please check the zlib home page 6http://www.zlib.org which may have more recent information. 7The lastest zlib FAQ is at http://www.gzip.org/zlib/zlib_faq.html 8 --- 7 unchanged lines hidden (view full) --- 16 The zlib sources can be compiled without change to produce a DLL. 17 See the file win32/DLL_FAQ.txt in the zlib distribution. 18 Pointers to the precompiled DLL are found in the zlib web site at 19 http://www.zlib.org. 20 21 3. Where can I get a Visual Basic interface to zlib? 22 23 See | 1 2 Frequently Asked Questions about zlib 3 4 5If your question is not there, please check the zlib home page 6http://www.zlib.org which may have more recent information. 7The lastest zlib FAQ is at http://www.gzip.org/zlib/zlib_faq.html 8 --- 7 unchanged lines hidden (view full) --- 16 The zlib sources can be compiled without change to produce a DLL. 17 See the file win32/DLL_FAQ.txt in the zlib distribution. 18 Pointers to the precompiled DLL are found in the zlib web site at 19 http://www.zlib.org. 20 21 3. Where can I get a Visual Basic interface to zlib? 22 23 See |
24 * http://www.winimage.com/zLibDll/ | |
25 * http://www.dogma.net/markn/articles/zlibtool/zlibtool.htm 26 * contrib/visual-basic.txt in the zlib distribution | 24 * http://www.dogma.net/markn/articles/zlibtool/zlibtool.htm 25 * contrib/visual-basic.txt in the zlib distribution |
26 * win32/DLL_FAQ.txt in the zlib distribution |
|
27 | 27 |
28 4. compress() returns Z_BUF_ERROR | 28 4. compress() returns Z_BUF_ERROR. |
29 30 Make sure that before the call of compress, the length of the compressed 31 buffer is equal to the total size of the compressed buffer and not 32 zero. For Visual Basic, check that this parameter is passed by reference 33 ("as any"), not by value ("as long"). 34 | 29 30 Make sure that before the call of compress, the length of the compressed 31 buffer is equal to the total size of the compressed buffer and not 32 zero. For Visual Basic, check that this parameter is passed by reference 33 ("as any"), not by value ("as long"). 34 |
35 5. deflate() or inflate() returns Z_BUF_ERROR | 35 5. deflate() or inflate() returns Z_BUF_ERROR. |
36 37 Before making the call, make sure that avail_in and avail_out are not 38 zero. When setting the parameter flush equal to Z_FINISH, also make sure 39 that avail_out is big enough to allow processing all pending input. 40 Note that a Z_BUF_ERROR is not fatal--another call to deflate() or 41 inflate() can be made with more input or output space. A Z_BUF_ERROR 42 may in fact be unavoidable depending on how the functions are used, since 43 it is not possible to tell whether or not there is more output pending 44 when strm.avail_out returns with zero. 45 46 6. Where's the zlib documentation (man pages, etc.)? 47 48 It's in zlib.h for the moment, and Francis S. Lin has converted it to a 49 web page zlib.html. Volunteers to transform this to Unix-style man pages, | 36 37 Before making the call, make sure that avail_in and avail_out are not 38 zero. When setting the parameter flush equal to Z_FINISH, also make sure 39 that avail_out is big enough to allow processing all pending input. 40 Note that a Z_BUF_ERROR is not fatal--another call to deflate() or 41 inflate() can be made with more input or output space. A Z_BUF_ERROR 42 may in fact be unavoidable depending on how the functions are used, since 43 it is not possible to tell whether or not there is more output pending 44 when strm.avail_out returns with zero. 45 46 6. Where's the zlib documentation (man pages, etc.)? 47 48 It's in zlib.h for the moment, and Francis S. Lin has converted it to a 49 web page zlib.html. Volunteers to transform this to Unix-style man pages, |
50 please contact Jean-loup Gailly (jloup@gzip.org). Examples of zlib usage 51 are in the files example.c and minigzip.c. | 50 please contact us (zlib@gzip.org). Examples of zlib usage are in the files 51 example.c and minigzip.c. |
52 53 7. Why don't you use GNU autoconf or libtool or ...? 54 55 Because we would like to keep zlib as a very small and simple 56 package. zlib is rather portable and doesn't need much configuration. 57 58 8. I found a bug in zlib. 59 --- 12 unchanged lines hidden (view full) --- 72 /usr/X11R6/lib. Remove any old versions, then do "make install". 73 7410. I need a Delphi interface to zlib. 75 76 See the contrib/delphi directory in the zlib distribution. 77 7811. Can zlib handle .zip archives? 79 | 52 53 7. Why don't you use GNU autoconf or libtool or ...? 54 55 Because we would like to keep zlib as a very small and simple 56 package. zlib is rather portable and doesn't need much configuration. 57 58 8. I found a bug in zlib. 59 --- 12 unchanged lines hidden (view full) --- 72 /usr/X11R6/lib. Remove any old versions, then do "make install". 73 7410. I need a Delphi interface to zlib. 75 76 See the contrib/delphi directory in the zlib distribution. 77 7811. Can zlib handle .zip archives? 79 |
80 See the directory contrib/minizip in the zlib distribution. | 80 Not by itself, no. See the directory contrib/minizip in the zlib 81 distribution. |
81 8212. Can zlib handle .Z files? 83 84 No, sorry. You have to spawn an uncompress or gunzip subprocess, or adapt 85 the code of uncompress on your own. 86 8713. How can I make a Unix shared library? 88 89 make clean 90 ./configure -s 91 make 92 9314. How do I install a shared zlib library on Unix? 94 | 82 8312. Can zlib handle .Z files? 84 85 No, sorry. You have to spawn an uncompress or gunzip subprocess, or adapt 86 the code of uncompress on your own. 87 8813. How can I make a Unix shared library? 89 90 make clean 91 ./configure -s 92 make 93 9414. How do I install a shared zlib library on Unix? 95 |
96 After the above, then: 97 |
|
95 make install 96 97 However, many flavors of Unix come with a shared zlib already installed. 98 Before going to the trouble of compiling a shared version of zlib and 99 trying to install it, you may want to check if it's already there! If you 100 can #include <zlib.h>, it's there. The -lz option will probably link to it. 101 | 98 make install 99 100 However, many flavors of Unix come with a shared zlib already installed. 101 Before going to the trouble of compiling a shared version of zlib and 102 trying to install it, you may want to check if it's already there! If you 103 can #include <zlib.h>, it's there. The -lz option will probably link to it. 104 |
10215. I have a question about OttoPDF | 10515. I have a question about OttoPDF. |
103 104 We are not the authors of OttoPDF. The real author is on the OttoPDF web | 106 107 We are not the authors of OttoPDF. The real author is on the OttoPDF web |
105 site Joel Hainley jhainley@myndkryme.com. | 108 site: Joel Hainley, jhainley@myndkryme.com. |
106 | 109 |
10716. Why does gzip give an error on a file I make with compress/deflate? | 11016. Can zlib decode Flate data in an Adobe PDF file? |
108 | 111 |
112 Yes. See http://www.fastio.com/ (ClibPDF), or http://www.pdflib.com/ . 113 To modify PDF forms, see http://sourceforge.net/projects/acroformtool/ . 114 11517. Why am I getting this "register_frame_info not found" error on Solaris? 116 117 After installing zlib 1.1.4 on Solaris 2.6, running applications using zlib 118 generates an error such as: 119 120 ld.so.1: rpm: fatal: relocation error: file /usr/local/lib/libz.so: 121 symbol __register_frame_info: referenced symbol not found 122 123 The symbol __register_frame_info is not part of zlib, it is generated by 124 the C compiler (cc or gcc). You must recompile applications using zlib 125 which have this problem. This problem is specific to Solaris. See 126 http://www.sunfreeware.com for Solaris versions of zlib and applications 127 using zlib. 128 12918. Why does gzip give an error on a file I make with compress/deflate? 130 |
|
109 The compress and deflate functions produce data in the zlib format, which 110 is different and incompatible with the gzip format. The gz* functions in 111 zlib on the other hand use the gzip format. Both the zlib and gzip 112 formats use the same compressed data format internally, but have different 113 headers and trailers around the compressed data. 114 | 131 The compress and deflate functions produce data in the zlib format, which 132 is different and incompatible with the gzip format. The gz* functions in 133 zlib on the other hand use the gzip format. Both the zlib and gzip 134 formats use the same compressed data format internally, but have different 135 headers and trailers around the compressed data. 136 |
11517. Ok, so why are there two different formats? | 13719. Ok, so why are there two different formats? |
116 117 The gzip format was designed to retain the directory information about 118 a single file, such as the name and last modification date. The zlib 119 format on the other hand was designed for in-memory and communication 120 channel applications, and has a much more compact header and trailer and 121 uses a faster integrity check than gzip. 122 | 138 139 The gzip format was designed to retain the directory information about 140 a single file, such as the name and last modification date. The zlib 141 format on the other hand was designed for in-memory and communication 142 channel applications, and has a much more compact header and trailer and 143 uses a faster integrity check than gzip. 144 |
12318. Well that's nice, but how do I make a gzip file in memory? | 14520. Well that's nice, but how do I make a gzip file in memory? |
124 125 You can request that deflate write the gzip format instead of the zlib 126 format using deflateInit2(). You can also request that inflate decode 127 the gzip format using inflateInit2(). Read zlib.h for more details. 128 129 Note that you cannot specify special gzip header contents (e.g. a file 130 name or modification date), nor will inflate tell you what was in the 131 gzip header. If you need to customize the header or see what's in it, 132 you can use the raw deflate and inflate operations and the crc32() 133 function and roll your own gzip encoding and decoding. Read the gzip 134 RFC 1952 for details of the header and trailer format. 135 | 146 147 You can request that deflate write the gzip format instead of the zlib 148 format using deflateInit2(). You can also request that inflate decode 149 the gzip format using inflateInit2(). Read zlib.h for more details. 150 151 Note that you cannot specify special gzip header contents (e.g. a file 152 name or modification date), nor will inflate tell you what was in the 153 gzip header. If you need to customize the header or see what's in it, 154 you can use the raw deflate and inflate operations and the crc32() 155 function and roll your own gzip encoding and decoding. Read the gzip 156 RFC 1952 for details of the header and trailer format. 157 |
13619. Is zlib thread-safe? | 15821. Is zlib thread-safe? |
137 138 Yes. However any library routines that zlib uses and any application- 139 provided memory allocation routines must also be thread-safe. zlib's gz* 140 functions use stdio library routines, and most of zlib's functions use the 141 library memory allocation routines by default. zlib's Init functions allow 142 for the application to provide custom memory allocation routines. 143 144 Of course, you should only operate on any given zlib or gzip stream from a 145 single thread at a time. 146 | 159 160 Yes. However any library routines that zlib uses and any application- 161 provided memory allocation routines must also be thread-safe. zlib's gz* 162 functions use stdio library routines, and most of zlib's functions use the 163 library memory allocation routines by default. zlib's Init functions allow 164 for the application to provide custom memory allocation routines. 165 166 Of course, you should only operate on any given zlib or gzip stream from a 167 single thread at a time. 168 |
14720. Can I use zlib in my commercial application? | 16922. Can I use zlib in my commercial application? |
148 149 Yes. Please read the license in zlib.h. 150 | 170 171 Yes. Please read the license in zlib.h. 172 |
15121. Is zlib under the GNU license? | 17323. Is zlib under the GNU license? |
152 153 No. Please read the license in zlib.h. 154 | 174 175 No. Please read the license in zlib.h. 176 |
15522. The license says that altered source versions must be "plainly marked". So | 17724. The license says that altered source versions must be "plainly marked". So |
156 what exactly do I need to do to meet that requirement? 157 158 You need to change the ZLIB_VERSION and ZLIB_VERNUM #defines in zlib.h. In 159 particular, the final version number needs to be changed to "f", and an 160 identification string should be appended to ZLIB_VERSION. Version numbers 161 x.x.x.f are reserved for modifications to zlib by others than the zlib 162 maintainers. For example, if the version of the base zlib you are altering 163 is "1.2.3.4", then in zlib.h you should change ZLIB_VERNUM to 0x123f, and --- 6 unchanged lines hidden (view full) --- 170 name (or your company's name), and an email address to contact for help or 171 issues with the library. 172 173 Note that distributing a compiled zlib library along with zlib.h and 174 zconf.h is also a source distribution, and so you should change 175 ZLIB_VERSION and ZLIB_VERNUM and note the origin and nature of the changes 176 in zlib.h as you would for a full source distribution. 177 | 178 what exactly do I need to do to meet that requirement? 179 180 You need to change the ZLIB_VERSION and ZLIB_VERNUM #defines in zlib.h. In 181 particular, the final version number needs to be changed to "f", and an 182 identification string should be appended to ZLIB_VERSION. Version numbers 183 x.x.x.f are reserved for modifications to zlib by others than the zlib 184 maintainers. For example, if the version of the base zlib you are altering 185 is "1.2.3.4", then in zlib.h you should change ZLIB_VERNUM to 0x123f, and --- 6 unchanged lines hidden (view full) --- 192 name (or your company's name), and an email address to contact for help or 193 issues with the library. 194 195 Note that distributing a compiled zlib library along with zlib.h and 196 zconf.h is also a source distribution, and so you should change 197 ZLIB_VERSION and ZLIB_VERNUM and note the origin and nature of the changes 198 in zlib.h as you would for a full source distribution. 199 |
17823. Will zlib work on a big-endian or little-endian architecture, and can I | 20025. Will zlib work on a big-endian or little-endian architecture, and can I |
179 exchange compressed data between them? 180 181 Yes and yes. 182 | 201 exchange compressed data between them? 202 203 Yes and yes. 204 |
18324. Will zlib work on a 64-bit machine? | 20526. Will zlib work on a 64-bit machine? |
184 185 It should. It has been tested on 64-bit machines, and has no dependence 186 on any data types being limited to 32-bits in length. If you have any 187 difficulties, please provide a complete problem report to zlib@gzip.org 188 | 206 207 It should. It has been tested on 64-bit machines, and has no dependence 208 on any data types being limited to 32-bits in length. If you have any 209 difficulties, please provide a complete problem report to zlib@gzip.org 210 |
18925. Will zlib decompress data from the PKWare Data Compression Library? | 21127. Will zlib decompress data from the PKWare Data Compression Library? |
190 191 No. The PKWare DCL uses a completely different compressed data format 192 than does PKZIP and zlib. However, you can look in zlib's contrib/blast 193 directory for a possible solution to your problem. 194 | 212 213 No. The PKWare DCL uses a completely different compressed data format 214 than does PKZIP and zlib. However, you can look in zlib's contrib/blast 215 directory for a possible solution to your problem. 216 |
19526. Can I access data randomly in a compressed stream? | 21728. Can I access data randomly in a compressed stream? |
196 197 No, not without some preparation. If when compressing you periodically 198 use Z_FULL_FLUSH, carefully write all the pending data at those points, 199 and keep an index of those locations, then you can start decompression 200 at those points. You have to be careful to not use Z_FULL_FLUSH too 201 often, since it can significantly degrade compression. 202 | 218 219 No, not without some preparation. If when compressing you periodically 220 use Z_FULL_FLUSH, carefully write all the pending data at those points, 221 and keep an index of those locations, then you can start decompression 222 at those points. You have to be careful to not use Z_FULL_FLUSH too 223 often, since it can significantly degrade compression. 224 |
20327. Does zlib work on MVS, OS/390, CICS, etc.? | 22529. Does zlib work on MVS, OS/390, CICS, etc.? |
204 205 We don't know for sure. We have heard occasional reports of success on 206 these systems. If you do use it on one of these, please provide us with 207 a report, instructions, and patches that we can reference when we get 208 these questions. Thanks. 209 | 226 227 We don't know for sure. We have heard occasional reports of success on 228 these systems. If you do use it on one of these, please provide us with 229 a report, instructions, and patches that we can reference when we get 230 these questions. Thanks. 231 |
21028. Is there some simpler, easier to read version of inflate I can look at | 23230. Is there some simpler, easier to read version of inflate I can look at |
211 to understand the deflate format? 212 213 First off, you should read RFC 1951. Second, yes. Look in zlib's 214 contrib/puff directory. 215 | 233 to understand the deflate format? 234 235 First off, you should read RFC 1951. Second, yes. Look in zlib's 236 contrib/puff directory. 237 |
21629. Does zlib infringe on any patents? | 23831. Does zlib infringe on any patents? |
217 218 As far as we know, no. In fact, that was originally the whole point behind 219 zlib. Look here for some more information: 220 221 http://www.gzip.org/#faq11 222 | 239 240 As far as we know, no. In fact, that was originally the whole point behind 241 zlib. Look here for some more information: 242 243 http://www.gzip.org/#faq11 244 |
22330. Can zlib work with greater than 4 GB of data? | 24532. Can zlib work with greater than 4 GB of data? |
224 225 Yes. inflate() and deflate() will process any amount of data correctly. 226 Each call of inflate() or deflate() is limited to input and output chunks 227 of the maximum value that can be stored in the compiler's "unsigned int" 228 type, but there is no limit to the number of chunks. Note however that the 229 strm.total_in and strm_total_out counters may be limited to 4 GB. These 230 counters are provided as a convenience and are not used internally by 231 inflate() or deflate(). The application can easily set up its own counters 232 updated after each call of inflate() or deflate() to count beyond 4 GB. 233 compress() and uncompress() may be limited to 4 GB, since they operate in a 234 single call. gzseek() and gztell() may be limited to 4 GB depending on how 235 zlib is compiled. See the zlibCompileFlags() function in zlib.h. 236 237 The word "may" appears several times above since there is a 4 GB limit 238 only if the compiler's "long" type is 32 bits. If the compiler's "long" 239 type is 64 bits, then the limit is 16 exabytes. 240 | 246 247 Yes. inflate() and deflate() will process any amount of data correctly. 248 Each call of inflate() or deflate() is limited to input and output chunks 249 of the maximum value that can be stored in the compiler's "unsigned int" 250 type, but there is no limit to the number of chunks. Note however that the 251 strm.total_in and strm_total_out counters may be limited to 4 GB. These 252 counters are provided as a convenience and are not used internally by 253 inflate() or deflate(). The application can easily set up its own counters 254 updated after each call of inflate() or deflate() to count beyond 4 GB. 255 compress() and uncompress() may be limited to 4 GB, since they operate in a 256 single call. gzseek() and gztell() may be limited to 4 GB depending on how 257 zlib is compiled. See the zlibCompileFlags() function in zlib.h. 258 259 The word "may" appears several times above since there is a 4 GB limit 260 only if the compiler's "long" type is 32 bits. If the compiler's "long" 261 type is 64 bits, then the limit is 16 exabytes. 262 |
24131. Does zlib have any security vulnerabilities? | 26333. Does zlib have any security vulnerabilities? |
242 243 The only one that we are aware of is potentially in gzprintf(). If zlib 244 is compiled to use sprintf() or vsprintf(), then there is no protection 245 against a buffer overflow of a 4K string space, other than the caller of 246 gzprintf() assuring that the output will not exceed 4K. On the other 247 hand, if zlib is compiled to use snprintf() or vsnprintf(), which should 248 normally be the case, then there is no vulnerability. The ./configure 249 script will display warnings if an insecure variation of sprintf() will 250 be used by gzprintf(). Also the zlibCompileFlags() function will return 251 information on what variant of sprintf() is used by gzprintf(). 252 253 If you don't have snprintf() or vsnprintf() and would like one, you can 254 find a portable implementation here: 255 256 http://www.ijs.si/software/snprintf/ 257 258 Note that you should be using the most recent version of zlib. Versions 259 1.1.3 and before were subject to a double-free vulnerability. 260 | 264 265 The only one that we are aware of is potentially in gzprintf(). If zlib 266 is compiled to use sprintf() or vsprintf(), then there is no protection 267 against a buffer overflow of a 4K string space, other than the caller of 268 gzprintf() assuring that the output will not exceed 4K. On the other 269 hand, if zlib is compiled to use snprintf() or vsnprintf(), which should 270 normally be the case, then there is no vulnerability. The ./configure 271 script will display warnings if an insecure variation of sprintf() will 272 be used by gzprintf(). Also the zlibCompileFlags() function will return 273 information on what variant of sprintf() is used by gzprintf(). 274 275 If you don't have snprintf() or vsnprintf() and would like one, you can 276 find a portable implementation here: 277 278 http://www.ijs.si/software/snprintf/ 279 280 Note that you should be using the most recent version of zlib. Versions 281 1.1.3 and before were subject to a double-free vulnerability. 282 |
26132. Is there a Java version of zlib? | 28334. Is there a Java version of zlib? |
262 263 Probably what you want is to use zlib in Java. zlib is already included 264 as part of the Java SDK in the java.util.zip package. If you really want 265 a version of zlib written in the Java language, look on the zlib home 266 page for links: http://www.zlib.org/ 267 | 284 285 Probably what you want is to use zlib in Java. zlib is already included 286 as part of the Java SDK in the java.util.zip package. If you really want 287 a version of zlib written in the Java language, look on the zlib home 288 page for links: http://www.zlib.org/ 289 |
26833. I get this or that compiler or source-code scanner warning when I crank it 269 up to maximally-pendantic. Can't you guys write proper code? | 29035. I get this or that compiler or source-code scanner warning when I crank it 291 up to maximally-pedantic. Can't you guys write proper code? |
270 271 Many years ago, we gave up attempting to avoid warnings on every compiler 272 in the universe. It just got to be a waste of time, and some compilers 273 were downright silly. So now, we simply make sure that the code always 274 works. 275 | 292 293 Many years ago, we gave up attempting to avoid warnings on every compiler 294 in the universe. It just got to be a waste of time, and some compilers 295 were downright silly. So now, we simply make sure that the code always 296 works. 297 |
27634. Will zlib read the (insert any ancient or arcane format here) compressed | 29836. Will zlib read the (insert any ancient or arcane format here) compressed |
277 data format? 278 279 Probably not. Look in the comp.compression FAQ for pointers to various 280 formats and associated software. 281 | 299 data format? 300 301 Probably not. Look in the comp.compression FAQ for pointers to various 302 formats and associated software. 303 |
28235. How can I encrypt/decrypt zip files with zlib? | 30437. How can I encrypt/decrypt zip files with zlib? |
283 284 zlib doesn't support encryption. The original PKZIP encryption is very weak 285 and can be broken with freely available programs. To get strong encryption, | 305 306 zlib doesn't support encryption. The original PKZIP encryption is very weak 307 and can be broken with freely available programs. To get strong encryption, |
286 use gpg ( http://www.gnupg.org/ ) which already includes zlib compression. | 308 use GnuPG, http://www.gnupg.org/ , which already includes zlib compression. |
287 For PKZIP compatible "encryption", look at http://www.info-zip.org/ 288 | 309 For PKZIP compatible "encryption", look at http://www.info-zip.org/ 310 |
28936. What's the difference between the "gzip" and "deflate" HTTP 1.1 encodings? | 31138. What's the difference between the "gzip" and "deflate" HTTP 1.1 encodings? |
290 291 "gzip" is the gzip format, and "deflate" is the zlib format. They should 292 probably have called the second one "zlib" instead to avoid confusion 293 with the raw deflate compressed data format. While the HTTP 1.1 RFC 2616 294 correctly points to the zlib specification in RFC 1950 for the "deflate" 295 transfer encoding, there have been reports of servers and browsers that 296 incorrectly produce or expect raw deflate data per the deflate 297 specficiation in RFC 1951, most notably Microsoft. So even though the 298 "deflate" transfer encoding using the zlib format would be the more 299 efficient approach (and in fact exactly what the zlib format was designed 300 for), using the "gzip" transfer encoding is probably more reliable due to 301 an unfortunate choice of name on the part of the HTTP 1.1 authors. 302 303 Bottom line: use the gzip format for HTTP 1.1 encoding. 304 | 312 313 "gzip" is the gzip format, and "deflate" is the zlib format. They should 314 probably have called the second one "zlib" instead to avoid confusion 315 with the raw deflate compressed data format. While the HTTP 1.1 RFC 2616 316 correctly points to the zlib specification in RFC 1950 for the "deflate" 317 transfer encoding, there have been reports of servers and browsers that 318 incorrectly produce or expect raw deflate data per the deflate 319 specficiation in RFC 1951, most notably Microsoft. So even though the 320 "deflate" transfer encoding using the zlib format would be the more 321 efficient approach (and in fact exactly what the zlib format was designed 322 for), using the "gzip" transfer encoding is probably more reliable due to 323 an unfortunate choice of name on the part of the HTTP 1.1 authors. 324 325 Bottom line: use the gzip format for HTTP 1.1 encoding. 326 |
30537. Does zlib support the new "Deflate64" format introduced by PKWare? | 32739. Does zlib support the new "Deflate64" format introduced by PKWare? |
306 307 No. PKWare has apparently decided to keep that format proprietary, since 308 they have not documented it as they have previous compression formats. 309 In any case, the compression improvements are so modest compared to other 310 more modern approaches, that it's not worth the effort to implement. 311 | 328 329 No. PKWare has apparently decided to keep that format proprietary, since 330 they have not documented it as they have previous compression formats. 331 In any case, the compression improvements are so modest compared to other 332 more modern approaches, that it's not worth the effort to implement. 333 |
31238. Can you please sign these lengthy legal documents and fax them back to us | 33440. Can you please sign these lengthy legal documents and fax them back to us |
313 so that we can use your software in our product? 314 315 No. Go away. Shoo. | 335 so that we can use your software in our product? 336 337 No. Go away. Shoo. |